Question:
what are the best Image formats for different/specific Jobs?
Anti - Hero
2008-07-21 16:08:59 UTC
PNG
JPEG
TIFF
GIF

I know Jpegs are good for file compression for images but not so much on text, or when your gonna edit a lot of times.. and Gif are good for Web.. etc...

best answer for the most detailed! thanks
Six answers:
gregthedesigner
2008-07-21 16:42:49 UTC
JPEGs are your "normal" type of file format for anything, but mainly photos. But should only be used under certain circumstances. They can be huge files, with high quality for printing, or very small files with low quality for the web. They are better when used with images that have lots of different colored pixels, like a photo. It shouldn't be used for a small logo or basic shapes with color (use a gif). They can't be edited after saving to that filetype, especially if you need to change a word, which is why you want to keep the original handy (Photoshop file, illustrator file, etc.) Jpegs can't support transparency, meaning, you can't see through to whats behind it. The shape of an jpeg can only and always be a square. If your jpeg is a red circle, than the rest of it will be white to fill in the square (or rectangle).



PNG - is almost exactly like a jpeg, same specifications, except it will support transparency if you tell it too. This includes opacity (seeing through it if you want it semi-transparent), or an odd shape. The png will still be a square shaped file, but if you have a circle, you have the option of making the edges of it clear. PNGs aren't used as often as other formats, but they should.



TIFF - mainly exists only for print and friendly transfer of files from one systems to another. The cool thing about TIFFs is that they can keep certain elements applied to it from photoshop: Transparency, type styles, layers... If you have a photoshop file that you know you need to see on a computer that doesn't have photoshop, but you don't want to lose quality by saving it as a Jpeg, use a TIFF. If you use the correct settings, you can open the TIFF file in Photoshop and edit it as if it were a PSD (photoshop document). Very useful if you are sending a photoshop layout to a printer and you aren't sure if they have photoshop. If you send a TIFF, they'll be able to open it to print it.



GIFs - are only used for small web images like avatars, logos, or thumbnails. They have a tremendous loss of quality which is why you can see the pixel dots in the images. GIFs are best used for small files that aren't complex. If it's a logo, an image with only a few colors like a computer drawing, or a cartoon, use GIF. If its more complex or you need a better quality, larger sized file, use JPEG. A few cool things about GIFs is they can support transparency like PNGs, but aren't nearly as huge of files, but again, huge loss of quality there. They are also the ONLY kind of file format of its kind (except for SWF in some circumstances), that are able to be animated. The animated images you see people posting on your myspace are animated GIFs. Again, since GIFs are very low quality, the animations are never that smooth.





So:



JPEGs: good for more complex images, small or large

PNG: same as JPEGs but can have transparent items

TIFF: used for print or if you want to see a photoshop layout on other computers

GIF: small files used best for small images. Can be animated and transparent. Don't use it for complex images.
thraxy
2008-07-21 23:23:18 UTC
PNG and JPEG are good for digital images. JPEG is more widely used (supported in most cameras).



PNG was created as a replacement for GIF, but that doesn't seem to be happening anytime soon. It's got the image quality of JPEG, but supports transparency like GIF. So it's quite good for detail images where you need transparency. That could be some sort of web banner that overlaps text area or something like that.



JPEG is, as mentioned, supported in still cams. It doesn't support transparency, but is a really good small format for pictures. Pictures on websites should - in my humble opinion - always be JPEG.



GIF is excellent for 2D graphics. It works best with illustrations/graphics that are few colors. When making web headers and other not too detailed work, GIFs are preferred, because they can be much smaller (bite size) than the other formats, making them a lot faster to load.



That's just about all I know. Someone might know more detail.
anonymous
2008-07-21 23:13:57 UTC
I used to work for a newspaper:

-jpeg is good for on the web, for photos, etc.

-

Gifs are good for the web when you need crisp detail, eg: letters.



Tiffs are good when you want lossless pictures and a lower file size for in the actual layout of the paper. Ie: it's good enough to be printed full size. Jpegs aren't, neither are gifs in my opinion.



PNGs i don't use (anymore)
anonymous
2008-07-21 23:20:36 UTC
PNG's - I personally use them for web(like the background of a myspace page) and desktop wallpapers because of their lossless compression.



JPEG's - medium-sized photos and graphics



TIFF's - I don't have too much experience with these - but I ordered custom plaques once for an event and the company wanted our logo in tiff format. Not sure why :p http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tagged_Image_File_Format



GIF's - Good for really small images/images with not a lot of detail/animated graphics.



Hope this info helped.



-Adam
demon_aus
2008-07-21 23:39:20 UTC
IF the graphic is to end up being handed onto a professional graphic artist or to be used for high quality printing then record as TIFF.



JPEG & GIF are highly compressed for screen or low res presentation only.



PNG is not a highly common format.
sai
2008-07-21 23:11:28 UTC
jpeg is best bcos of less storage memory n compatibility


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...